Greenway Bust: Shame On Us – Well Most Of Us - For Not Seeing It Sooner
Monday, February 21st, 2011The Globe has finally written the obituary for all those fanciful plans to pack the Greenway with a bevy of new museums and cultural institutions.
The article was prompted by the YMCA of Greater Boston’s announcement it is canning plans to build a new downtown Y over highway ramps abutting this strip of downtown parkland.
It’s the last of a series of ambitious - and frankly pie in the sky projects - that stretches all the way back to the Massachusetts Horticultural Society’s ill-fated, $100 million Garden Under Glass.
While each of these projects had a different spin, all shared one thing in common: Huge costs and general inability to raise money.
Sorry, but these ridiculous Greenway plans should have been called out on the carpet years ago as the Big Dig was ending and old Central Artery was being dismantled.
Yes, even a decade ago it was becoming pretty clear that the idea that nonprofits like Mass Hort were going to pay for major development projects, one petunia sale at a time, was downright foolish.
I know, since I busy back in the early 2000s raising questions about Mass Hort’s efforts to keep its claim alive to a prime piece of the new Greenway next to South Station. (I was a business reporter at the Boston Herald at the time.) Others were as well – check out this devastating piece in 2003 by one of the Globe’s top editorial writers.
Back when Matt Amorello nearly ran the Turnpike into the ground in the early 2000s, the highway authority commissioned an expensive master planning process for the Greenway, complete with all sorts of fanciful drawings on what was supposed to go there.
Of course, Amorello and gang had no appetite for serious questions about how all this was going to get paid for. They did get a lot of free publicity, though, letting Matt play the role of big shot urban planner.
Of course, this was exactly the time that our local political, business and media leaders should have been taking a hard look at this Greenway fantasy, one in which cash-starved nonprofits pay for extravagant monuments to their backers, one bake sale at a time.
That didn’t happen and the Greenway fraud was allowed to live another decade.
Shame on all of us for that.


